Benge’s Hardware – Butler Tarkington
SHOP ONLINE
Shop thousands of Ace products online and choose Benge’s Hardware for convenient pickup or delivery.
STORE SERVICES
Screen repair, mower & small engine repair, key cutting, paint matching and delivery—all from your local Benge’s team.
GENERATORS
Protect your home with reliable backup power and professional generator installation through Benge’s and EleXcor.
B2B ACCOUNTS
Convenient purchasing solutions, personalized service and support for local businesses and professionals.
Store Hours
Open Daily Until 8pm
Sunday
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
8am–8pm
8am–8pm
8am–8pm
8am–8pm
8am–8pm
8am–8pm
8am–8pm
FOLLOW THIS STORE
About Benge’s Home Improvement Store in Midtown Indianapolis
Benge’s – Butler Tarkington is part of a growing family of 10 locally-owned hardware stores across central Indiana.
Whether you’re a homeowner tackling a weekend project at your house on Boulevard Place, a contractor stocking up for work at a jobsite near Butler University, or a small business owner on Restaurant Row who needs supplies fast, our friendly, knowledgeable associates make a quick trip stay a quick trip.
Serving the Butler Tarkington neighborhood and surrounding communities since August 8, 2025. Benge’s has three other locations within Indianapolis city limits: Irvington, Franklin Township, and Perry Township. View all Benge’s locations.
Formerly known as Benge’s Hardware – Midtown.
Convenient Shopping Every Day, Right in Your Neighborhood
Our Butler Tarkington hardware store (in the northwest quadrant of the old city limits of Indianapolis) stocks major brands across every category, including grills, griddles, and smokers; lawn mowers, snow blowers, and other outdoor power equipment; exterior and interior paint and stains—plus, whole-home generators, hardware, hand tools, power tools, and all the accessories and gear needed for construction and woodworking.
We also carry lawn care goods (including fertilizers, herbicides, and pesticides), portable and whole-house generators, plumbing supplies, everyday essentials like cleaning supplies for project cleanup (such as heavy-duty degreasers and mold/mildew removers), and even specialty goods from local makers.
Our In-Store Services
We’re here to make your to-do list a lot easier. From everyday projects to specialized repairs, Benge’s Hardware – Butler-Tarkington offers convenient in-store services backed by a local team that’s ready to help. Stop in for screen repair, mower and small engine repair, key cutting, paint matching, delivery and more.
- Paint color matching and custom paint mixing
- Window screen replacement & repair
- Sharpening lawn mower blades
- Mower & Small Engine Repair
- Wire, rope, and chain cutting
- Glass sheet cutting and acrylic sheet cutting
- Key cutting, key duplication, and auto key fob programming
- Propane tank refill and propane tank exchange
- Carpet cleaning rental
Commercial Sales
Get everything you need to take your business to the next level and get the job done. Benge’s near Butler University in Indianapolis, Indiana offers contractors and commercial buyers easy one-stop shopping, bulk order savings, priority customer service, speedy deliveries, and special savings on supplies.
Find out more about our Benge’s Pro program or contact Landon on our B2B team to learn how you can unlock savings and other loyalty perks with a Benge’s professional account.